With artificial intelligence making headlines almost daily, it’s understandable that parents are asking more questions about how their children’s photographs are created.
Was that background added? Has the photograph been edited? Is it even a real photograph?
At PicDay, we welcome those questions. Parents deserve to understand what they are buying and how it has been produced.
But there is an important distinction between a professionally photographed and edited portrait and an image generated by AI.
A beautiful photograph starts with a camera
Long before editing begins, a great deal of work goes into creating a photograph.
Lighting, camera settings, posing, composition and helping a child feel comfortable all contribute to the finished result. Knowing how to capture a natural expression matters just as much as knowing how to use the equipment.
Photography is an art. A polished, beautifully lit portrait is the result of creative decisions, technical knowledge and experience.
Yet AI is now so firmly in people’s minds that when they see an impressive photograph, their first reaction can be: “That must be AI.”
In a way, that can feel like a compliment to the standard of work being produced. But it can also overlook the photographer’s skill and the work that went into creating the image.
Editing is part of photography
Professional photography has never ended with pressing the shutter.
In the days of film, photographers made adjustments in the darkroom. Today, editing software helps photographers prepare their images for print and online galleries.
At PicDay, our green-screen approach allows us to photograph each person individually and then present them against a choice of backgrounds. It also enables us to build team and whole-club photographs from individual portraits.
Those finished images involve editing and compositing. The people within them have been photographed by us.
An added background does not mean the child has been generated by AI. A team composite does not mean the players are artificial. These are photographic techniques that require careful preparation and attention to detail.
Some modern editing tools also include AI-assisted features. That makes it even more important to explain what a tool actually does, rather than treating every use of the term “AI” as meaning the same thing.
Questions are welcome. Assumptions can cause harm.
We understand why parents want reassurance, particularly when photographs involve their children.
However, there is a difference between asking how an image was made and publicly stating that a photographer’s work is “just AI” without checking.
An unfounded comment can cause other parents to question whether the photographs are authentic, whether they represent good value, or whether the business has been honest about its work.
For a small photography business, that can damage trust, affect orders and put future bookings at risk. Behind the finished photograph are people investing their time, equipment, creativity and care into their work.
We are not asking parents to stop asking questions. We are asking them to give photographers the opportunity to answer before an assumption becomes an accusation.
Let’s keep the conversation open
If you are unsure about something in a PicDay photograph, please ask us.
We would much rather explain our process than leave you wondering. You can contact us at info@picday.co.uk, and we will be happy to help.
Technology will continue to change photography, but a beautiful image should still be an opportunity to appreciate the creativity and craftsmanship behind it.
Sometimes, the photograph that looks “too good to be real” is simply a real photograph, carefully created.
